Barking: The Alternate Versions (Disc 2)

[bryantm3]

Originally Posted by TheBang

You Do Scribble (Abbey Road Version) is different from You Do Scribble on CD2.

what are the differences??

[TheBang]

drums drums drums (and guns and rock)

[Vancouver]

Originally Posted by TheBang

You Do Scribble (Abbey Road Version) is different from You Do Scribble on CD2.

Excellent. Thanks for the info.

[testudo]

junkies, criminals, fugitives...

[twicezero]

This is probably one of those only the poster can hear it things

but take a listen to Mmm Skyscraper I Love You (Live Jam) from Lemonworld Broadcast 2006-05-13 - round about the 6 minute mark. the bits that aren't traditionally there.

take a listen to the start of Always Loved A Film (Lemonworld Mix)

similar, or do io need coffee?

[jose m]

Originally Posted by testudo

no. are you? quoting out of context is wrong, always.

The point is if you give a very rough version that is similar to the final, the shiny sparkling version will look better. I have seen many fine art documentaries that always show this.

you knew what i mean.
how is it an insult to the fans?

[khouri]

The demo version of Diamond Jigsaw on the Barking bonus disc is, as Karl said, NOTHING like Underworld. No synths, just guitar, rock drum sounds and Karl's singing. It's a fun, upbeat little ditty but definitely not Underworld.

I like PVD's remix a lot but I'm afraid the awesome synthpop version from the Las Vegas show will remain the best version of this divisive Underworld track.

Similarly, the version of "Moon in Water" that we first heard during a radio broadcast was incalculably better than the version found on the bonus disc, and arguably better than High Contrast's version.

The same can be said for the early versions of Always Loved a Film.

I think Rick should accept that he can nail a track sooner than he thinks! Diamond Jigsaw, ALAF, Moon in Water, You Do Scribble....

[potatobroth]

YDS is great to have in these two forms. Oddly enough, the catchiness of Scribble does get stuck in my head and i end up singing it even though I don't really like it.

Both YDS and YDS (Abbey Road) are FANTASTIC. Great additions to this release.

Strumpet is okay. Kinda miss the "gets much better" piece from the electraglide show so many years back.

All in all, its like a fantastic release of Bsides. Love it.

[potatobroth]

OK, I know we don't want to do this, but I'm gonna have to agree with whoever said Grace (Telematic Peal Mix) is the better version. It's pretty great. The album version is great too, but something more Underworld about the alt.

[Sappys Curry]

Originally Posted by khouri

I like PVD's remix a lot but I'm afraid the awesome synthpop version from the Las Vegas show will remain the best version of this divisive Underworld track.

Seems to be the case for 2008 live Strumpet, too. Bird 1 is good, a stand out track on Barking, but those darn synth plops have me liking the live version of Strumpet a bit more.